Mixing dry aquarium fertilisers

May 14, 2020 7 min read

Mixing dry aquarium fertilisers

 

What are dry fertilisers?

Dry aquarium fertilizers refers to fertilizers that come as pure chemical salts. These salts dissolve in water to provide the necessary nutrients to plants. They are extremely concentrated as they come in pure chemical salt format. Most commercial fertilizers are made from the same base salts - except that they are pre-mixed with water and come with dosing instructions. However, hobbyists can buy the dry salts straight from dry powder merchants. 

For example, one can buy a bottle of XXX brand "potassium" liquid fertilizer to add potassium to your planted tank. That bottle can instead be replaced by dosing the dry salt K2SO4/potassium sulfate for a fraction of the cost. Indeed if we subject the contents of commercial fertilizers to lab analysis, most of them are made up of these similarly available salts.

The difficulty of mixing your own is two part - first, in the handling of different salts required to cover all the nutrients. Second, doing the measuring and calculations to come up with dosage rates for a certain tank. However, most of the salts are non-hazardous and easy to handle, and with online calculators available, coming up with your own dosing solutions is easy.

What you need

First of all you need the dry salts. The essential nutrients as mentioned in earlier sections are NPK, Fe + Traces, and perhaps Ca/Mg if your water is lacking in these. For each nutrient there is an associated salt that contains it. Some salts provide more than 1 type of nutrient.

COMMON SALTS
Potassium Potassium sulfate (K2SO4), Potassium chloride (KCl), Potassium nitrate (KNO3), Monopotassium phosphate (KH2PO4).
Nitrogen Potassium nitrate (KNO3), Calcium nitrate (Ca(NO3)2.4H2O)
Phosphorus ​Monopotassium phosphate (KH2PO4), Dipotassium phosphate (K2HPO4)
Magnesium Magnesium sulfate (MgSO4)
Iron Iron is a reactive element and Iron fertiliser should come in chelated format - this means that the iron atom is bound to a chelating agent, which keeps it in Fe2+ oxidation state which is preferable for plant uptake, rather than being oxidised into (Fe3+) state. Many trace element mixes such as Plantex CSM + B already contain iron and you do not require additional iron if using those mixes.
Traces These come under common packages that contain all 5 essential trace elements: Plantex CSM + B, MicroMix plus, Miller's Microplex, Plant-prod Micro mix, TNC Trace

 

Dry fertsDry fert in bottles

EQUIPMENT

MIXING BOTTLES

One way to add nutrients to the tank is to dose dry salts directly into the tank water and let it dissolve in the tank environment. However, many aquarists prefer mixing their own dosing solutions - which may contain a few different salts. This removes the need to measure each salt when dosing is done. Mixing solutions also allow greater precision for dosing into small tanks. For example, the amount of Phosphate salt a small tank requires may be so small that it is hard to measure - diluting a larger amount of dry salt into a solution and dosing the solution gives greater accuracy. ​

WEIGHING SCALE / MEASURING DEVICE

A weighing scale accurate to at least 1 gram​; many kitchen scales do. Seachem sells a digital measuring spoon accurate to 0.1 grams for around 20 USD. So if you're going to spend money on a weighing scale anyway, can consider it. If on a super tight budget where cost minimisation is the priority, using a set of accurate measuring spoons will work too - there will be some margin of error, but planted tanks work in a wide enough range that it won't matter most of the time. Plastic spoons don't rust after interaction with salts unlike metal ones.

Measuring SpoonPlastic Spoons

How to measure Dry Salts

Firstly, target levels for nutrients in tank is quoted in ppm (parts per million). ​So when someone say that they have 1 ppm of nitrates in the tank, this means that for the given mass of water in the tank, divide it by a million and that is the mass of nitrates available in the tank. So 1 ppm of nitrates in a tank that has 1 million kg of water, means that the tank contains 1 kg of nitrates > (1 out of 1 000 000).

​The target levels for each nutrient is different and this is covered on the page on nutrient dosing approaches. EI for example, recommends dosing up to 30ppm of potassium in a week.

How does one measure a dose for 30ppm of potassium for a 100 litre tank size?
We can easily make use of online nutrient dosing calculators such as this one
This approach demonstrates dosing the dry powder directly into the tank.

​1. Enter your tank size in the column

Dry fert calculator tank size

2. Click on "DIY"

Click on DIY

3. Next select your compound. We will use K2SO4 (potassium sulfate) in this demo. Then click on "dry dosing". This means that we will be adding the dry salt directly into our tank. 

4. Next choose "Dose to reach a target" under the column "I am calculating for"
5. Since we have a target of 30ppm of K, enter 30ppm in the "My target is" box.

5. Press the calculate button. The results will come out on the right side. In this scenario, to get 30ppm of potassium into a tank of 100 litres, we would need to add 6.69grams of the salt K2SO4 into the  aquarium.

Alternatively we can use the calculator to estimate the result of a certain dose. For example, if we only have teaspoons and am wondering how much potassium would 1 teaspoon of K2SO4 add to the tank of 100 litres.

Click on "I am calculating for" column and choose "Result of my dose"
​Then enter the dose of K2SO4 that you would add to the tank. In this demo we chose 1 teaspoon.
The results then appear on the right hand side: 1 teaspoon of K2SO4 to our 100 litre tank will add 28.72ppm of potassium to our tank.

Creating a dosing solution

The next approach demonstrates dosing fertilizer through creating a dosing solution. I.e. making your own liquid fertilizer.
Steps 1 & 2 are the same as above. However, instead of clicking dry dosing we click "A solution" under the column "Using"

3. Enter your container size. This refers to the volume of the fertilizer solution that you are going to create. Here we choose to use a 500 ml bottle.

4. Dose size refers to the dose of liquid fertilizer solution that you are going to add into your aquarium each time you dose. This may vary depending on the size of your aquarium, and frequency of dosage. In this case we entered 20ml as our dosage size. "My target is" column refers to the amount of ppm you want added to the tank when you do 1 dose, here we entered 10ppm. This means that we expect our 20ml solution to add 10ppm of potassium to our tank.

5. Click on the calculate button and the site will tell you that you need to add 55.71grams of K2SO4 to your 500ml bottle of solution. Each 20ml dose would then add 10ppm of potassium to the tank. If you have selected a target dose that is too high, or dosage size that is too small, the site will give you the warning that one cannot dissolve so much of a particular salt in the volume of water. In this case we need to tweak the dosage size, or target ppm. Alternatively, we can choose chemicals/salts that are more soluble.

Similar to dry dosing, one can use the "Result of my dose" option under "I am calculating for" column to get an estimate of how much ppm our dose adds to a tank if we dissolved the indicated amount of salt in our solution bottle. Here the estimation is that if we dissolve 50 grams of K2SO4 in 500ml of water, a 10ml dose of the solution into a 100 litre tank would give 4.49ppm of K. Again, if you enter too large an amount of salt to be dissolved in the container size, a warning message would appear.

 WALKTHROUGH EXAMPLE

Here we go through making a macros (NPK) and micros (Fe/Traces) dosing solution. The reason to have 2 bottles is that phosphates can bind to iron easily, creating an insoluble precipitate, so keeping them in separate bottles prevents that. We would dose each bottle on Mon/wed/fri. While phosphates and iron would bind in a concentrated solution - the dilution in the tank environment prevents this from happening, so dosing on the same day is fine.

Firstly, let us define our target variables.

1. We want to dose only 3 times a week, on Monday/Wed/Fri.

2. We need to define our target levels:

Each dose of our macro solution will add:

  • 4ppm Potassium (12ppm per week)
  • 3ppm Nitrates (9ppm per week)
  • 1ppm Phosphates (3ppm per week)
  • 1ppm Magnesium (3ppm per week)

Each dose of our micros solution will add:

  • 0.1ppm Iron/traces (iron used as a proxy) (0.3ppm per week)

In addition, we would be using 500ml bottles for each solution.
The salts we would use:

For macro solution:

  • KCl - provides Potassium
  • KNO3 - provides both Potassium & Nitrates
  • KH2PO4 - provides both Potassium & Phosphates
  • MgSO4 - provides Magnesium


For micros solution:

  • Plantex CSM + B - provides iron/traces

So we enter the nutrient dosing calculator website.

1. Enter aquarium size (for example, 46gallons)
2. Choose "DIY"
3. we'll start with calculating for KNO3, which provides both potassium and nitrates
4. Choose "A solution"
5. Our container size is 500ml
6. Each dose we would want to add to the tank is 10ml - we estimate that this is a reasonable dosage size for this tank
7. Choose "Dose to reach a target" 
8. Our target for NO3 is 3ppm as from above.
9. Press calculate.

On the right hand side, the calculator tells us that we have to add about 43 grams of KNO3 to our dosing solution to get 3ppm per dose for nitrates.
We repeat the steps for KH2PO4, MgSO4 by changing the chemical selected at step 3. & dosing target at step 8.

Lastly we would calculate for KCl.
As KNO3 and KH2PO4 both add potassium to the tank, we need take that into account.
Our target is 4ppm of potassium per dose.
KNO3 and KH2PO4 already add (1.9ppm + 0.4ppm of potassium), so we just need to add 1.7ppm more K. (4ppm - 1.9ppm - 0.4ppm)
We enter 1.7ppm as our target at step 8. after choosing KCl at step 3.

Summarizing the above:

For our Macro dosing solution of 500ml:
​500ml water
28.2 grams of KCl
42.6 grams of KNO3
12.5 grams of KH2PO4
88.3 grams of MgSO4
(rounding off to the nearest gram is fine)

10ml per dose of the above will add the below to our 46 gallon tank:
​4ppm Potassium
3ppm Nitrates
1ppm Phosphates
1ppm Magnesium

For our Micros dosing solution, it's a single step process
​500ml water
13.3 grams of Plantex CSM + B

10ml per dose of the above will add the below to our 46 gallon tank:
0.1ppm Fe
Traces as proportionate ratio to Fe above.



Also in Fertilizers

When do I start dosing fertilizer into a newly setup planted tank?
When do I start dosing fertilizer into a newly setup planted tank?

March 05, 2020 1 min read

The short answer is that you should start dosing water column fertilizers as soon as you have plants in the new tank and no later.

New plants have no established root system, which limits their ability to draw nutrients from the soil.

Read More
'No ferts, no dosing, no CO2' planted tanks, how valid are they?
'No ferts, no dosing, no CO2' planted tanks, how valid are they?

January 11, 2020 2 min read

This seductively easy path is unfortunately heavily based on survivorship bias. The few examples that do make it are paraded as the norm when it is not a dependable method for most folks.
Read More
Analysis of the ADA nutrient dosing approach
Analysis of the ADA nutrient dosing approach

September 05, 2019 4 min read

An overview of the ADA philosophy and approach to fertilization for planted tanks.
Read More

Subscribe